Rural-Urban
Migration and Informal Sector of Dhaka City: Issues and Facts
Ahsan
Abdullah
Lecturer, Department of Public
Administration, Jahangirnagar University, Savar, Dhaka-1342, Bangladesh.
ABSTRACT:
Rural-urban migration is one of the common features of
developing countries. Bangladesh is not an exception. Dhaka is the capital city
of Bangladesh. Rapid growth of Dhaka city is the result of excessive
rural-urban migration that has made the Dhaka city as one of the mega cities in
the world. Many factors work to force or influence the rural poor people to
migrate to urban areas or cities. Rural poverty, inadequate job opportunity,
natural disaster etc. force the rural poor people to migrate to the cities,
especially to Dhaka city. On the other hand, employment opportunity in informal
sector of Dhaka city motivates the rural poor to come in the city. Living
opportunities in Dhaka city also motivate the people to migrate to the city.
This study has given attention on both the urban destination and the rural
origin of the migrants. Many poor people who cannot survive in the rural areas
migrate to Dhaka city and involve in the informal sector and earn their
livelihood.
KEYWORDS:
Rural-Urban Migration,
Informal Sector, Rural Poverty, Livelihood, Employment Opportunity.
1. INTRODUCTION:
Rural-urban migration is a very common scene in
Bangladesh. Many people migrate to urban areas or cities every year. About 500,000 people move to Dhaka city every
year from rural areas (1). Rural-urban migration is the
movement of people from rural areas to urban areas. It is a state where rural
people change their residence from rural to urban area permanently or
temporarily. There are many causes of rural-urban migration. This is happened
mostly for earning livelihood. Many issues existed in rural areas like poverty,
inadequate job opportunity, natural disasters etc work as the push factors of
rural-urban migration. Dhaka city provides the largest portion of job
opportunity in Bangladesh. Despite the growth of formal industrial sector and
other employment opportunities, Dhaka is dominated by the presence of a huge
informal sector of economic activities. About 65% of all employment in the city
is in the informal sector (2). Illiterate or less
educated and unemployed people of rural areas migrate to Dhaka city on regular
basis because of its employment opportunity in the informal sector and living
opportunity in the slum areas. Informal sector is conceptually defined to
include all economic activities which are not recognized and regulated by the
government (3).
The government of Bangladesh has taken some policies
regarding rural-urban migration but the issues in rural and urban areas have
not been considered. The policies are only for the urban formal sector.
However, rural-urban migration is considered as the survival strategy and
informal sector of Dhaka city is considered as the livelihood opportunity for
the rural poor people.
2. METHODOLOGY OF THE STUDY:
This study has been conducted by the
secondary source of data. Secondary data and information have been collected
from articles, books, newspapers and internet sources. For the purpose of this
study, some theoretical literatures have been reviewed.
3.
CONCEPT OF MIGRATION, RURAL-URBAN MIGRATION AND INFORMAL SECTOR:
Migration is the relocation of living place and
workplace at the same time. When it happens from rural to urban area it is
called rural-urban migration. Various terminologies have been developed by
scholars and researchers and criteria such as space, time and purpose of
movement have been considered to define the concept of migration or rural-urban
migration. Peterson (1958) developed a classification of migration in which he
tried to distinguish between migration as a mechanism of changing the way of
life as well as preserving it. According to his classification, a migration
typology is distinguishable by i.e. temporary and permanent, distance i.e.
short and long, boundaries such as internal and international, involvement of
areal units such as communities, countries, states etc., decision making such
as voluntary or forced, numbers such as mass or individual, political such as
free or sponsored, causes such as economic and non-economic, aims such as
innovative and conservative. Hagerstand defines ‘migration as a change of home
and workplace at the same time’. The United Nations has defined migration as
‘the change of residence from one civil division to another for a period of one
year or more’ (4). Finally, rural-urban migration is a
state when the way of life of the people is changed by changing the residence
from rural to urban area within a country.
Informal sector is conceptually defined to include all
economic activities which are not officially recognized and regulated and which
operate outside the incentive system offered by the government and its
institutions. It is also called the urban subsistence sector or unorganized
sector or unenumerated sector (3). The informal sector or informal economy is that part of an
economy that is not taxed, monitored by any form of government, or included in
any gross national product (GNP), unlike the formal economy (5).
The informal sector is also characterized by a large number of small scale
production and service activities that are individually or family owned and
uses labour intensive and simple technology. The people of informal sector are
engaged in some types of activities such as hawking, street vending, letter
writing, knife sharpening, junk collecting etc. Most of the workers of informal
sector are migrants from rural areas unable to find employment in the formal
sector (6).
4.
ISSUES IN RURAL AREAS:
Most of the rural people of Bangladesh live below
poverty line. Most of them are illiterate or less educated. They are engaged in
producing and managing crops and livestock. But they do not have adequate land
to cultivate. Many of the rural poor people live in the areas that are prone to
extreme annual draught, flooding, cyclone which cause huge damage to their
crops, homes and livelihoods. In order to rebuild their homes, they often have
to resort to moneylenders, NGOs etc. that bring deeper poverty. In addition,
these natural disasters also cause outbreaks of cholera, typhoid and other
waterborne and diarrhoeal diseases which affect them physically and make lower
their productivity levels. Some major issues of rural areas of Bangladesh which
force the rural poor people to migrate to urban areas especially to Dhaka city
are discussed below:
4.1: Poverty
The population in Bangladesh is predominantly rural,
with almost 80 percent of the population live in rural areas. Many people live
in rural areas that lack of quality services such as education, health clinics,
adequate roads etc. About 36 percent of the population in rural areas lives
below the poverty line. They suffer from persistent food insecurity, inadequate
land and assets etc. They are often uneducated and may also suffer from serious
illnesses or disabilities. Another 29 percent of the rural population is
considered moderately poor. Though they may own a small plot of land and some
livestock and generally have enough to eat, their diets lack nutritional
value. Women are among the poorest of
the rural poor, especially when they are the sole heads of their households.
They suffer from discrimination and have few earning opportunities and their
nutritional intake is often inadequate (7).
4.2: Inadequate Job
Opportunity
There are two sectors in job area. These are formal
and informal sectors. Most of the rural people of Bangladesh are engaged in
informal, low-income jobs with limited productivity. Most of them are involved
in agricultural activities. However, because of rapid urbanization the amount
of farmland is shrinking and high population growth creates enormous pressure
on the country's natural resources – especially on arable land. That is why
most of rural households do not acquire enough land and many have no land. So,
they have little scope to work. In many cases they provide labor to others for
both farm and nonfarm activities inside and outside their villages. But they cannot
meet their demand by this way. In addition, floods, cyclones and drought damage
the crops every year. So, people become hopeless. Meanwhile, few rural
industries are unable to meet the demand for jobs and forcing many rural poor
people to seek work in urban areas, especially in the Dhaka city (8).
4.3: Natural Disasters
Bangladesh is called as a land of natural disasters
because she is attacked by different types of natural disasters almost every
year. Every year some common natural disasters like floods, cyclones,
landslides, tidal bores, earthquake and drought attack on Bangladesh. Among all
the natural disasters, floods and cyclones are most common because of their
regularity and destruction history. They visit especially in the rainy season
(9). Bangladesh is particularly vulnerable to climate
change. Two thirds of its territory is less than 5 meters above sea level,
making it one of the most flood-prone countries in the world. Severe flooding
during monsoons can cause significant damage to crops and property and an
adverse impact on rural livelihoods. Climate change seems likely to add to the
destruction by monsoon floods, and the frequency of cyclones may increase. Poor
people of rural areas are hit hardest because they are more densely concentrated
in badly constructed housing on land that is prone to hazards. In a word,
natural disasters cause a heavy loss in our country and cause untold suffering
to people, especially to the poor people. Natural disasters create poverty and
poverty causes population displacement. Poverty in Bangladesh is especially
persistent in three areas: the north-west, which is affected by droughts and
river erosion; the central northern region, which is subject to serious
seasonal flooding that limits crop production; and the southern coastal zones,
which are affected by soil salinity and cyclones (8).
By analyzing population displacement in major natural
events like flood and cyclone over 40 years (1970-2009), it has been found that
on an average 25% (39 million) and 2% (3 million) populations in each major
flood and cyclone are displaced. A major flood used to happen in every 4 years
from 1970-1989, while the frequency of major flood occurrence has been
increased in every 3 years from 1990-2009. Though, frequency of one or more
severe disasters in a year has already been experienced in Bangladesh like the
year 2007 (Cyclone Sidr and flood) and 2009 (Cyclone Aila and Cyclone Bijli),
but in future occurrence of major natural events in every year might not be a
surprise (10).
4.4: Others
Some poor people leave their villages because they
mortgage their land and take money from moneylenders or from the influential
people of the rural areas but are not able to pay it back and thus lose the
mortgaged land or property. Some people migrate due to the torture unleashed on
them by the influential quarters of the villages. Political dispute also compel
people to migrate to the city. Some poor people take loan from NGOs and they
cannot use this money for appropriate purpose. They spend all credit loans for
their own family consumption or repairing houses. This default of credit pushed
them to migrate to cities. In cities they are engaged in informal working
professions and earn money. For returning instilment they go to villages and
after payment they come back to city. For this system a lot of poor migrants
stay in city areas for permanently (11).
5.
UNEQUAL JOB OPPORTUNITIES AND DISPARITY IN INCOME BETWEEN RURAL AND URBAN
AREAS:
Formal and informal sector jobs are existed in both
rural and urban areas. But there is huge inequality in job opportunities
between rural and urban areas. Moreover, people get less amount of money from
any type of job in the rural areas while they get 2/3 times greater amount of
money by performing same type of jobs in the urban areas or in Dhaka city. There is still considerable inequality in the
distribution of income between rural and urban populations. In general, the
urban population, in the areas around Dhaka, Chittagong, and other large
cities, has long been involved in small and medium sized businesses or employed
in various industries and in informal sector. They benefited from the recent
growth and have higher incomes. Meanwhile, the rural population experience
chronic shortages of land and regular floods and cyclones, which often a within
matter of hours sweep away the results of months of hard work. The 1988, 1998,
2004 floods, for example, affected two-thirds of the country, wiping out the
entire winter crop and displacing millions of people (12).
6.
EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITIES IN DHAKA CITY:
Employment in Dhaka city is divided into two broad
categories which are the formal and the informal sectors. The formal sector
includes occupations such as banking, office clerks, physician, lawyer etc. The
informal sector includes the works of street vendor, hawker, cobbler,
carpenters, barbers etc. Considerable
amount of employment are ensured by this sector (13).
It has been estimated that about 65% of all employment in the city is in the
informal sector (2).
Illiterate and less educated rural poor people are
attracted by the informal sector of Dhaka city because they do not have enough
job opportunities in rural areas. Rural migrants may not get employment
immediately after the migration to the city. The majority of the new migrants
are seemed to create their own employment and start their own business or work
for small-scale family run enterprises. The self-employed migrants are engaged
in various types of activities such as street vending, knife sharpening, selling
fireworks etc. Other migrants find jobs as barber, carpenter, mechanic,
cobbler, maid servant, hotel boy etc.
The majority of the people entering in the informal
sector are recent migrants who are unable to find jobs in the formal
sector. By involving in the informal
sector activities the migrants can utilize their skills to make livelihood.
Although living conditions and working conditions in the city may not be better
than that in the rural areas, the income in informal sector in the city is
higher than that in the rural areas. Migrants, who are interested in getting
employment in the formal sector, find the informal sector as a safety net to
fall back on if things do not work out for them. The informal sector is
therefore seen as a cause of rural-urban migration, because it lowers the risk
of the individual being unemployed once they move to the cities (14).
7.
LIVING OPPORTUNITIES OF THE POOR MIGRANTS IN DHAKA CITY:
In Dhaka city, the migrated people have enough living
opportunities. Generally the poor migrants who migrate to Dhaka city for
searching work involve them in the informal sector and take their shelter in
the slum areas. In 2010, it has been projected that upto 60% of the total
population of the city are living in the slums (15).
Slums in Dhaka city have been growing rapidly since 1971. Several surveys on
slum growth in Dhaka, conducted by Centre for Urban Studies (CUS) recorded slum
populations 275,000 in 1974, 718,143 (2,156 slums) in 1991, 1.5 million (3007
slums) in 1996 and 3.4 million (4,966 slums) in 2005 (16).
According to the trend of the slum growth in the city the
present number of slum would be more than 7000. Trend of growth shows
that slum population increased two times more than previous count and it has
been increasing since 1991 (10). The Bangladesh Bureau
of Statistics (BBS) will conduct the country's second full census on slum and
floating population in all the city corporation areas in 2014 (17). There are also a large number of messes and
small houses in Dhaka city and many poor people live there. So, it can be said
that living opportunities of the poor migrants in Dhaka city is considerably
high though the condition of living places are not good.
8.
RURAL TO URBAN MIGRATION AS LIVELIHOOD STRATEGY:
In Bangladesh, migration has long been an important
livelihood strategy for the rural poor people. The rural population is
increasing and the cultivable land area is decreasing day by day. So, land
ownership of per person is also decreasing. Limited land ownership at the household
level compels people to induce rural-urban migration in two ways. Firstly,
those who have some parcel of land, but it cannot provide work to them for all
the year-round, migrate for partial fulfillment of their household requirements
e.g. clothes, medicines, household commodities, agricultural inputs etc. It is
called seasonal migration. Secondly, those who have no land or very small
parcel of land migrate to the cities permanently in the hope of getting
livelihoods alternatives (3). Rural poor people migrate
to the cities, especially to the Dhaka city to earn basic livelihoods. Poor
people involve them in various types of informal works after migrating to the
city to earn money and meet the demand of their families. Many migrants in
Dhaka city improve their life by involving them in informal sector activities.
In the rural areas livelihood of the poor people is hampered by many ways.
Overpopulation, natural disasters etc. create unemployment in the rural areas.
People search out the ways by which they can relieve from poverty. To exempt
from the poverty rural poor identify rural to urban migration as the best
strategy.
9.
POLICIES AND PROGRAMMES OF GOVERNMENT:
Since independence, poverty reduction and economic
growth were the major focus of the policy of every government of Bangladesh. In
the 1980s, privatization and liberalization were given priority while
development of human resources gained ascendancy from the 1990s. Then the draft
national policy for economic growth and poverty reduction aims for pro-poor
economic growth, human development, women’s advancement and closing the gender
gap, closing the gap between rich and poor, social safety nets and
participatory governance. Due to scarcity of land the government faces the
daunting challenge of generating employment for a labour force that is growing
faster than the population. Whilst agriculture and rural development are the
cornerstones of the present strategy and non-farm activities are rapidly
expanding. The government formulated the National Rural Development Policy 2001
to enhance the capacity and power of the rural poor people to develop, protect
and sustain their livelihoods. The government allocates around 20% of the
development budget for local government and rural development. The government has
also outlined both medium and long-term issues to be covered under governance
and rural development, ranging from law and order, local governance, better
service delivery and rural infrastructure. But the policies and programmes
regarding rural development are not implementing properly. That is why people
are migrating to Dhaka city and other urban areas to search work for their
livelihood on regular basis.
Since independence, the government had no internal
migration policy till the recent past. The government has also failed to
develop secondary towns and peri-urban areas. At last the government of
Bangladesh has taken some policies regarding rural-urban migration. The
government wants to influence the direction of internal flows of population,
and that only indirectly, through policies of industrial decentralization. The
assumption is that if industries and satisfactory and accessible services can
be established in peri-urban areas and secondary cities, then migrants will
avoid congested city centres and the larger cities in the country (18). But the policy is only for the urban formal sector. It
should be mentioned that most of the rural poor people involve in the informal
sector activities after migrating to the city. By this type of policy no people
who are attracted by the informal sector of Dhaka city can be encouraged to
migrate to peri-urban or secondary cities instead of Dhaka city. Because they
are encouraged to migrate to Dhaka city attracted by its very large informal
sector. So, informal sector based separate migration policy is needed according
to the future plan of the government.
10.
CONCLUSION:
Rural-urban migration is happened for achieving basic
needs. In many cases it is also for finding better and secured place to live
in. Rural-urban migration is rapidly increasing due to some push and pull
factors. Push factors are those which force a person to move to the urban area
or city. Floods, drought, famine,
inadequate job opportunity, overpopulation etc. are included in the push
factors. Pull factors are those which encourage a person to leave the native
area. Job and living opportunities are included in the pull factors. In
Bangladesh some issues in rural areas such as poverty, natural disasters, and
inadequate job opportunities etc. work as push factors which force the rural
people to migrate to the cities especially to Dhaka city. On the other hand,
employment and living opportunities of Dhaka city attract the rural poor to
come to the city. Informal sector of Dhaka city provides huge employment
opportunity to the rural poor. The recent migrants can easily search out their
shelter in the slum areas. So, the poor people who are in acute problems in the
rural areas can take migration decision easily.
11.
REFERENCES:
1. Friedman, Lisa (2009), “A city exploding with climate migrants”,
Bangladesh and Climate Migration, Climate wire, Environment and Energy
(E&E). Available from: URL:
http://www.eenews.net/public/climatewire/2009/03/16/1
2. World Bank. Towards an Urban Strategy for Bangladesh, Infrastructure Unit, South
Asia Region, World Bank, Washington DC. 1999.
3. Timalsina, Krishna Prasad. Rural Urban
Migration and Livelihood in the Informal Sector: A Study of Street Vendors of Kathmandu
Metropolitan City, Nepal, Master of Philosophy Thesis in Development Studies,
Submitted to the Department of Geography, Norwegian University of Science and
Technology (NTNU), Trondheim, Norway, Available
from: URL: ntnu.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:122401/FULLTEXT01.pdf
4. Huq-Hussain, Shanaz. Female Migrant’s Adaptation in Dhaka: A Case of the Process of Urban
Socio-Economic Change, Urban Studies Programme, Department of Geography,
University of Dhaka. 1996.
5. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Informal_sector
6. Todaro, Michael P. and Smith, Stephen C. Economic Development, Delhi: Pearson
Education Ltd. 2008.
7. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Poverty_in_Bangladesh
8. http://www.ruralpovertyportal.org/country/home/tags/bangladesh
9. http://collegiatebd.blogspot.com/2013/02/natural-calamities-of-bangladesh.html
10. http://www.bdresearch.org/home/index.php?option=com_content
andview=articleandid=174:migrationandlivingconditionsinurbanslumsimplicationsforfoodsecurityandcatid=111:urbanisationandItemid=130
11. Farhana, Khandaker Mursheda and Rahman, Syed Ajijur and Rahman Mahfuzur (2012),
“Factors of Migration in Urban Bangladesh: An Empirical Study of Poor Migrants
in Rajshahi City”, Bangladesh e-Journal of Sociology,
Volume 9, Number 1, Available from: URL:
http://www.eldis.org/go/country-profilesandid=62953andtype=Document#.UpC2cNkbhdg
13.
Alam, Md., Nazmul. A Socio-economic Study
of Informal Sector Workers of Dhaka City, Bangladesh e-Journal
of Sociology, Volume 9, Number 2, Available from: URL: http://www.eldis.org/go/homeandid=62941andtype=Document#.UpC1_9kbhdg
14.
McCatty, Machel. The Process of Rural-Urban Migration in Developing Countries,
An essay submitted to Department of Economics, Carleton University, Available
from: URL: www1.carleton.ca/economics/ccms/wp-content/ccms-files/he...
15.
http://www.perspectivebd.com/slums-in-dhaka-city-life-of-misery/
16.
Centre for Urban Studies (CUS). Slums of urban Bangladesh, Mapping and Census.
2005.
17. http://www.thefinancialexpress-bd.com/print.php?ref=MjBfMDlfMTNfMTNfMV8zXzE4MzMxNg==
18.
Siddiqui, Tasneem. Migration and Development – Pro-Poor Policy Choices, Dhaka:
The University Press Limited. 2005.
Received on 12.03.2016
Modified on 08.04.2016
Accepted
on 23.04.2016
© A&V Publications all right reserved
Research J. Humanities and Social Sciences. 7(2):
April - June, 2016, 101-106
DOI: 10.5958/2321-5828.2016.00017.6